Skip to main content

Building on a Shaky Foundation




Dear Speculators,

The value of Naira has changed, the price of crude oil has appreciated significantly from January last year but nothing really has changed in the way Nigerian government carelessly plans and budget for the year ahead. 

A budget is too important to be built on a shaky foundation. The 2017 budget is far too important considering the current economic recession in Nigeria. Keynes strategy of an expansive fiscal policy during economic slowdowns seems to be the country's favoured approach to pulling the economy out of recession. It's a goldilocks strategy considering it pushes Nigeria further into debt at a time when the cost of borrowing in the country is too high but the benefit of increased spending in the country is too important to ignore.

Budget estimates for 2017 will see Nigeria spending beyond N7.4 trillion, a 21 percent increase to last year record spending which was still unable to prevent the country from entering a recession. Crude oil price benchmark is $44.50 but today's crude oil price is only $49, leaving very little safety room for the country in a situation where new information about an oil glut causes an oil price shock which pushes crude oil price below $45. Remember crude oil revenue accounts for over 70 percent of federal government revenue, so any price shock that causes oil price to drop to $44 or below will force Nigeria to accrue more debt to fund its record budget.

Another discomfort is why the country is always over ambitious when estimating its proposed daily crude oil production as 2.2 million barrels per day when it only averaged daily production of 1.9 million bpd in the past year. Wishful estimates won't get us far. It is better to underestimate and end up with savings than to overestimate and end up with debt. 

Finally, we wrote a piece earlier this year about the potential confusion Central Bank can create by allowing multiple exchange rates in a country which is now materializing. Nigeria is proposing to apply an exchange rate figure of 305 N/$ which is almost a 20 percent discount of the rate CBN is selling dollar to Nigerian banks. Whether the budget will be used to subsidize the dollar further or the wealth of Nigeria will be thrown out the window using accounting tricks is yet to be seen. The exchange rate should be more reflective of the NAFEX price and not the inter-bank rate since Nigeria does not in anyway appear to be a bank.

Emeka Ucheaga,
Managing Partner,
Emeka Ucheaga Advisory

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ECOWAS: The Silent Opportunity of a Weaker Naira

Dear Speculators, The catastrophic collapse in the value of Naira in 2016 has brought more bad news than good news to Nigeria. This has come at a time when currency manipulation in Japan, China and Switzerland to purposely erode the value of their currency in order to gain trade advantages has angered many foreign governments especially America. Britain was lucky to have had the Pound devalued by the financial markets in the aftermath of the Brexit to the delight of the Bank of England whom like many other Central Banks in the western world are now inflation seekers. But not Nigeria, we don't need a weaker Naira, at least not now. Unfortunately, the drastic fall in the oil price, current account deficit, lower foreign external reserves and withdrawal of foreign investments from Nigeria has dragged the Naira about 58% lower since its January levels at the interbank market. This has almost doubled the rate of inflation in the last one year as imported products make up a si...
Post a Comment
Read more

Everything is Going Down in Nigeria Except Inflation

Dear Speculators, The wait is over, we anticipated bad news and we got it. Our fears have become reality, the economy has continued to back slide and Nigeria has officially tipped into a recession. Not that this surprises anyone though. Falling oil prices, dollar scarcity, exploding oil pipelines, massive labour retrenchment and import restrictions have all contributed their fair share to weaken growth in Nigeria's economy. However, the stock market arguably has had it worse than the general economy this year as the market is currently down about 3.8 percent against an economy contraction of 2.06 percent in the second quarter. A closer analysis of the stock market brings to light some intriguing statistics. The largest 49 companies in the stock market account for 97% of the total stock market capitalization. 41 companies of the 49 sell at an average of 22x earnings. Only 49 companies out of a total of 171 companies trading on the Nigerian Stock Exchange are valued above ...
Post a Comment
Read more

CBN: Understanding the Mind of the MPC

Dear Speculators, For the fifth time this year, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Central Bank of Nigeria will seat to decide on new monetary policies to influence the general economy to achieve their policy objectives. These objectives can be broken into four macroeconomic goals; economic growth, full employment, price stability, and exchange rate stability. The main policy tool of the MPC is the monetary policy rate (MPR) which is the rate at which the CBN lends money to banks. Now it is almost impossible for the MPC to marry all the objectives by simply using interest rates. This is because while raising rates may favour the last two objectives, it is unfavourable to the first two objectives and vice versa. Understanding what drives each of these objectives is very important. Economic growth is achieved through an increase in productivity in the economy, either through technology or an increase in skilled labour. Even zero rates in America and Europe hasn't ...
Post a Comment
Read more