External Debt Financing is a Bad Idea for now

Dear Mr President,

Nigeria expects to raise about 900 billion naira from external sources to fund the budget deficit. It seems like a pretty good idea, with interest rates at historical low levels in developed economies, debt financing has never looked more attractive. But in the world of finance, what is obviously right can be the wrongest decision. Naira has slid an average of 19% annually against the greenback in the last 30 years. Today we see dollar trading at ridiculously high levels in the parallel market, not to mention the value of pounds and euros against the naira in the foreign exchange market. If Nigeria begins to binge borrow externally from the rest of the world, then we must deploy the funds to increasing our export capacity in order to increase foreign exchange earnings. It is imperative that the debt should not be directed at local investments because if interest rates from America is around 0.25% and annual naira depreciation rate is 19%, the real cost of borrowing from abroad will be around 20% per annum. As it is, it is obvious that internal borrowing is cheaper than external borrowings as our local bonds are priced between 10-11% per annum.

The best use of zero interest rates abroad is for debt refinancing. Once America moves to join Japan at negative interest rates, our best course of action is to borrow to pay off existing debt, not take new ones for investment purposes. This will reduce the total amount of external debt owed by Nigeria.

We understand the government wants to grow the economy and we support this good initiative but it will be a grave mistake to borrow from abroad to support the local economy without first rectifying the persistent naira depreciation issue. A word is enough for the wise, even the blind can foresee the crisis ahead if this mistake is made.

Signed:
Emeka Ucheaga,
Managing Partner,
Emeka Ucheaga Advisory
+2348137532722
emekaucheaga@gmail.com

Comments

ECOWAS: The Silent Opportunity of a Weaker Naira

Dear Speculators, The catastrophic collapse in the value of Naira in 2016 has brought more bad news than good news to Nigeria. This has come at a time when currency manipulation in Japan, China and Switzerland to purposely erode the value of their currency in order to gain trade advantages has angered many foreign governments especially America. Britain was lucky to have had the Pound devalued by the financial markets in the aftermath of the Brexit to the delight of the Bank of England whom like many other Central Banks in the western world are now inflation seekers. But not Nigeria, we don't need a weaker Naira, at least not now. Unfortunately, the drastic fall in the oil price, current account deficit, lower foreign external reserves and withdrawal of foreign investments from Nigeria has dragged the Naira about 58% lower since its January levels at the interbank market. This has almost doubled the rate of inflation in the last one year as imported products make up a si...

Everything is Going Down in Nigeria Except Inflation

Dear Speculators, The wait is over, we anticipated bad news and we got it. Our fears have become reality, the economy has continued to back slide and Nigeria has officially tipped into a recession. Not that this surprises anyone though. Falling oil prices, dollar scarcity, exploding oil pipelines, massive labour retrenchment and import restrictions have all contributed their fair share to weaken growth in Nigeria's economy. However, the stock market arguably has had it worse than the general economy this year as the market is currently down about 3.8 percent against an economy contraction of 2.06 percent in the second quarter. A closer analysis of the stock market brings to light some intriguing statistics. The largest 49 companies in the stock market account for 97% of the total stock market capitalization. 41 companies of the 49 sell at an average of 22x earnings. Only 49 companies out of a total of 171 companies trading on the Nigerian Stock Exchange are valued above ...

CBN: Understanding the Mind of the MPC

Dear Speculators, For the fifth time this year, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Central Bank of Nigeria will seat to decide on new monetary policies to influence the general economy to achieve their policy objectives. These objectives can be broken into four macroeconomic goals; economic growth, full employment, price stability, and exchange rate stability. The main policy tool of the MPC is the monetary policy rate (MPR) which is the rate at which the CBN lends money to banks. Now it is almost impossible for the MPC to marry all the objectives by simply using interest rates. This is because while raising rates may favour the last two objectives, it is unfavourable to the first two objectives and vice versa. Understanding what drives each of these objectives is very important. Economic growth is achieved through an increase in productivity in the economy, either through technology or an increase in skilled labour. Even zero rates in America and Europe hasn't ...

Emeka Ucheaga Advisory

Search This Blog