Skip to main content

All that Glitters is not Gold



Dear Speculators,

A lot of people wrongfully determine cheap stocks by the naira value of its shares. We on the other hand believe Price to Earnings ratio to be a better determinant of a cheap or expensive security. If the PE ratio is unreasonably high, it is too expensive and if it is unreasonably low, it is very cheap. We use the word unreasonable because like Prof Bruce Greenwald of Colombia University pointed out, we live in a world of two extremes. We always believe we are 100% right so when we are wrong, we are 100% wrong, nothing less. As we act on our beliefs, we may drive prices either too high or pull prices too low such that on the average we are both right and wrong.

To a large extent, the naira value of a share unit depends heavily on how a company chooses to dilute ownership. For example Company A worth 10 billion naira may sell 100 million shares valued at 100 naira per share and have earning power of 50 naira per share such that the PE ratio is only 2. Company B on the other hand valued at 20 billion naira may choose to sell 1 billion shares valued at 20 naira per share but have earning power of 4 naira per share such that its PE ratio is 5. At 1st glance it appears that the nominal value of company B stocks are cheaper than company A stocks because company A shares are 5 times higher than company B shares but in reality, company B shares are more expensive than that of company A because the return on equity of company A is much greater than that of company B. Company A has a lower PE ratio than company B so we are paying more for a single share unit of Company A but the return is 2.5 times greater than the return at Company B.

PS: Low PE ratio may also mean high risk or high leverage business so it is necessary to research on the company before purchasing its shares. There may be a good reason why the market priced it so low. This sort of analysis is only relevant for companies in the same industries or similar lines of business. All that Glitters isn’t Gold!

Signed:
Emeka Ucheaga,
Managing Partner,
Emeka Ucheaga Advisory

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Wrong Forecaster

Dear Speculators, The gloominess of the Nigerian economic outlook has significantly knocked down the prices of some financial assets but the real value of some of these assets have been mildly affected. While recounting the economic misfortune that has befallen the country in the last two years is inevitable, dwelling on the past is a perfect time wasting activity. Luckily, investment is forward looking and not regressive thinking. The past is a great indication of the future but not a mirror for prediction. The randomness of the world ensures that yesterday looks at least slightly different from tomorrow. And if we have learnt anything from the history books, it is that good things do not last forever and bad times always have an end. Life is by definition cyclical. The key questions to ask before buying or selling any financial asset is; will the current economic situation last forever? Will the inflation rate remain in double digits over the next 5 years? Will the Nai...
Post a Comment
Read more

It's a Dip not a Bear

Despite strong economic fundamentals and fairly optimistic market sentiments that have driven stock market prices in the past year and even stronger since the start of 2018, stock markets all around the world are witnessing an unexplained coordinated price descent in the past one week. Asides the biggest bitcoin price crash in years, now 66% lower than its record high price of $19,500 in December, nothing out of the ordinary has occurred. Yes, stock prices are at the highest it's been in since pre-crisis era in U.S and the market is due for a price correction but then how do we explain market dips in relatively cheap emerging markets? Something is amiss! As Central Bankers around the world have begun to discuss monetary tightening in a coordinated fashion as the quest for 2% inflation seems more achievable this year due to strong global economic and rising commodity prices, bond prices have dropped precipitously and the U.S 10 year Treasury bills risen above 2.5% a...
Post a Comment
Read more

Everything is Going Down in Nigeria Except Inflation

Dear Speculators, The wait is over, we anticipated bad news and we got it. Our fears have become reality, the economy has continued to back slide and Nigeria has officially tipped into a recession. Not that this surprises anyone though. Falling oil prices, dollar scarcity, exploding oil pipelines, massive labour retrenchment and import restrictions have all contributed their fair share to weaken growth in Nigeria's economy. However, the stock market arguably has had it worse than the general economy this year as the market is currently down about 3.8 percent against an economy contraction of 2.06 percent in the second quarter. A closer analysis of the stock market brings to light some intriguing statistics. The largest 49 companies in the stock market account for 97% of the total stock market capitalization. 41 companies of the 49 sell at an average of 22x earnings. Only 49 companies out of a total of 171 companies trading on the Nigerian Stock Exchange are valued above ...
Post a Comment
Read more